Truly, Actuality TV Is not A “Responsible” Pleasure

by 

As of late, my weeknight schedule is packed. On Tuesday nights, I’m glued to Dancing with the Stars. I reserve Wednesdays for the brand new episodes of The Actual Housewives of New York, and on Thursdays, I pivot to my ladies in Salt Lake Metropolis. I have to see the brand new season of Love is Blind and, after all, I already binged The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives in a single weekend. It’s formally actuality TV season, and actually, I’m swamped.

With on a regular basis I spend watching actuality TV, you’d suppose I’ve at all times been a die-hard fan, however it wasn’t at all times like this. For years, I dismissed the style as trash—senseless content material for zoning out that didn’t enchantment to me. I’ll admit, I believed it was a little bit beneath me. I’d have a lot reasonably watched a high-budget scripted drama that I may “get one thing out of.”

Now, after a whole 180 on the style, I’m a staunch defender of actuality TV and refuse to really feel responsible for my obsession. Sure, it’s usually over-the-top, however there’s actual worth within the tales it tells. Right here’s what modified my thoughts concerning the “trashiest” type of tv.

Why actuality TV issues

Actuality TV attracts us in on a premise of exuberant wealth, unattainable existence, competitors, intercourse, or drama. These hooks are additionally the explanations folks might look down on it. These themes are fashionable throughout media, however once they’re on a non-scripted tv present, out of the blue, they’re “responsible pleasures.” Like different genres with a predominantly feminine viewers—resembling romance novels and pop music—actuality TV faces disproportionate scrutiny. Simply because actuality TV invitations criticism doesn’t imply it lacks worth. Listed below are some explanation why actuality TV deserves a more in-depth look:

It facilities ladies’s tales

One of the highly effective facets of actuality TV is its capacity to place ladies’s tales entrance and middle in a method that few different genres do. Because the meme says, “We’d like extra advanced feminine characters, however you couldn’t even deal with her,” cue pictures of Rachel Berry, Cassie Howard, Rory Gilmore, Hannah Horvath, or some other broadly criticized feminine character. However in actuality TV, we not solely deal with them—we welcome them. The extra fascinating, flawed, or contradictory a feminine actuality TV star is, the higher. We’re not restricted to narratives about nice love or storylines with ladies as victims of horrible crimes, however we’re in a position to see the on a regular basis lives of girls, regardless of how messy they’re.

After all, some actuality TV exhibits do pit ladies towards one another—there’s no denying it. Nevertheless, the viewers additionally sees how ladies navigate these conflicts, rebuild their friendships, and assist one another when it issues most. In The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, for instance, we see a good friend group criticize one another and battle over petty exclusions, like Jen Affleck uninviting a number of the ladies to her child blessing occasion for not being “Mormon sufficient.” Even after that drama, the women all stand by Jen when her husband, Zac, berates her through textual content.

As these ladies’s lives evolve, their exhibits develop with them. Within the Housewives franchise alone, we see ladies discovering their sexuality after divorce, battling substance abuse points, combating infertility, and discovering their method out of abusive relationships. Actuality TV doesn’t drive characters to remain the identical for seasons on finish—it exhibits the ebb and move of their realities. Sure, these critical subjects are damaged up by fights, however that doesn’t erase the truth that they’re central to the style.

Actuality TV exhibits the complexities of human relationships

Past specializing in ladies’s narratives, actuality TV additionally offers us a uncooked glimpse into the intricacies of human relationships, from the bonds of friendship to the fallout of betrayal (there’s no heartbreak like a plot twist elimination in Survivor). Conflicts that appear too trivial to function a plotline in common TV often is the foundation of a number of episodes in actuality TV. They’re additionally the issues we wrestle with in our actual lives. Actuality TV highlights how folks navigate sophisticated friendship dynamics, face rumors, and be taught to apologize and rebuild after a battle. It’s an intriguing character examine that not many exhibits can provide.

With actuality TV, you can even step into worlds you may by no means in any other case expertise, gaining perception into new existence and empathizing with the challenges that include them. I’ve no private connection to the Mormon faith or the state of Utah, however after watching The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, I really feel rather more conversant in each. It’s only one perspective, after all, and there are numerous completely different experiences inside that group, however I nonetheless left the present with a brand new understanding. Actuality TV grants entry to lives you won’t have skilled so intimately in any other case. Even the seemingly good lives of the elite on exhibits like The Actual Housewives of Beverly Hills, you may unravel to disclose layers of complexity beneath the dazzling floor of Hermès baggage and Cartier jewellery.

It supplies cultural documentation and commentary

Tv has lengthy served as a historic and cultural reference level. Evaluating Fifties scripted exhibits like I Love Lucy to The Actual Housewives of Orange County, which aired in 2009, exhibits how a lot the position of girls within the dwelling and society has advanced—and actuality tv is a big a part of that. Even these early days of Housewives and the brand new The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, we see the variations in what was trending, how folks acted, the expertise, and the slang they used. Actuality TV offers us a snapshot of how occasions have modified.

Most of the criticisms folks use to discredit actuality TV are simply the shortcomings of our world taking part in out as it’s on our screens. Take The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, for instance. Is it the ladies’s fault they preach empowerment inside the Mormon religion in a single scene after which need to ask their husband’s permission earlier than becoming a member of an outing within the subsequent? Or is it an sincere portrayal of girls grappling with their roles in a faith that emphasizes the authority a husband has over his household? Are The Actual Housewives creating unrealistic magnificence requirements with every new season, as they seem on display with ever-smoother pores and skin and fewer positive traces? Or are they merely merchandise of a society that refuses to let ladies in media age?

Sure, it may be uncomfortable to face these realities, however so is studying a nonfiction e-book. Actuality tv is simply nonfiction plus leisure worth. With tough modifying and overly produced scenes, it could not at all times provide a very unbiased or goal view of humanity, however it at all times brings up precious questions concerning the state of the world as it’s.

It means that you can join with others

My ardour for actuality TV is how some folks really feel about sports activities groups. I’ve my favourite gamers, and there’s normally a particular staff I’m rooting for. Solely, as a substitute of the drama unfolding on a discipline, it’s set within the freshly purchased McMansion of a actuality star.

While you discover out one other particular person can also be a fan of actuality TV, it’s precisely like assembly somebody who’s a fan of the identical sports activities staff. You may go over participant stats (yap about what number of Instagram followers Devin misplaced after that heinous Bachelorette finale), speculate about who’s going to win the following sequence championship (talk about whether or not Whitney will nonetheless personal the villain storyline on the following season of The Secret Lives), and even place your bets (forged your vote on Dancing With The Stars). For myself and lots of different ladies, actuality TV is a supply of group—and that’s simply as necessary as a bunch of bros watching the Tremendous Bowl.

Its leisure worth is next-level

For all its cultural relevance and deep insights, perhaps essentially the most vital cause we tune into actuality TV is the unparalleled leisure it supplies. A lot of leisure right this moment revolves round excessive stakes: Crime dramas, superhero motion pictures, and fantasy exhibits appear to rule streaming providers. Actuality TV can’t depend on the identical otherworldly drama, so that they use interpersonal battle and relationships to maintain folks hooked. It’s campy and over-the-top, mimicking the fun of getting juicy gossip from a good friend with out inviting drama into your life.

I’m no stranger to criticism over my love for actuality TV, and within the years since I began watching it, I’ve heard all of it. Answering the easy query, “Have you ever watched something good these days?” can shortly result in a condescending eye roll, a scoff adopted by, “However have you ever watched any actual TV?” Each time I encounter one in every of these reactions, I do know that even when it’s unconscious, it’s coming from a spot of undermining ladies’s pursuits.

In the event you’re an unyielding actuality TV naysayer, perhaps it’s time to ask your self: Are you actually so fast to miss a whole style as a result of it’s “trashy,” or is it as a result of the one method you’ll take ladies’s tales critically is that if they’re completely packaged in content material that feels extra respectable to you (like a moody Max authentic with a feminine detective lead, an all-male directing staff, and a suspenseful rating)? You don’t have to affix our Golden Bachelorette watch events, however please spare us the discuss the way you “by no means watch actuality TV” prefer it makes you higher than the remainder of us. Let the women have this one and gallop off into the sundown in your extremely excessive horse to look at a documentary or one thing.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Lauren Blue, Life-style Employees Author

As a Life-style Employees Author for The Everygirl, Lauren ideates and writes content material for each aspect of our readers’ lives. Her articles span the subjects of dwelling decor, scrumptious recipes, hobbies, journey itineraries—and every thing in between. When she isn’t testing the newest TikTok development, she may be discovered scouring Instagram for stunning houses to function on the positioning.